Jean-Paul Valley Jr. was bred by the Sacred Order of St. Dumas to be their champion. Jean-Paul was brainwashed and unaware of the Order and the split-personality even prevented him from knowing what he was doing as Azrael. Azrael would kill his targets. Even though they were evil, Batman did not approve of this. He managed to repair the damage caused by the Order of St. Dumas to Jean-Paul’s mind and convinced him to adopt his own ethics. Azrael grew close to Batman and Robin (Tim Drake), and even replaced Batman in the Bat-suit when Bruce Wayne’s back was broken by Bane.
- Ability: Brain-washing (After only having 1/10 health points left for the first time, 4 points will automatically be restored. He then will attack and automatically defeat one random villain. However...)
- Weakness: Brain-washing (...he won't be able to continue through the game afterwards until a hero defeats him.)